Skip to main content
FFL Transfer Fees
New Jersey FFL Industry News

Third Circuit Destroys NJ's AR-15 Ban—Now SCOTUS Needs to Finish the Job

September 9, 2026

Alright, folks, here's some news that should make every gun owner in the Garden State pay attention. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals just handed us a huge win—New Jersey's unconstitutional bans on semiautomatic rifles and standard-capacity magazines have been ruled unconstitutional. Let me break down what happened and why it matters.

In a 10-5 decision, the full Third Circuit recognized what we've been saying all along: you can't ban commonly owned firearms just because politicians don't like them. We're talking about roughly 24 million AR-15s and similar rifles in circulation, plus over 100 million 30-round magazines. These aren't exotic weapons—they're everyday guns owned by everyday Americans for lawful purposes.

Here's the frustrating part: while the ruling is a victory for our rights, the court stayed its decision while New Jersey gears up to petition the Supreme Court. So for now, those unconstitutional restrictions remain on the books. Garden State gun owners are still stuck under laws that a federal appellate court has already said violate the Second Amendment. That's absurd.

What's really interesting is that several Democrat-appointed judges joined the majority. Judge Arianna Freeman, a Biden appointee, actually wrote the opinion! Meanwhile, Judge Patty Shwartz's dissent shows exactly how anti-gun judges try to work around Heller and Bruen—basically arguing that because these guns look "military," they aren't protected "arms" at all. That's nonsense. With over 40 million military-pattern rifles in civilian hands representing about 8% of all firearms, yet used in less than 3% of murders, the "dangerous" argument falls apart.

The Supreme Court is already set to hear similar cases from Illinois and Connecticut next year, and there's a good chance they'll fold New Jersey into that. This is the moment we've been waiting for—SCOTUS has a chance to make these rulings stick nationwide and tell states like New Jersey that they can't keep playing games with our constitutional rights.

Until then, we wait. But the momentum is on our side.